It’s Not My Fault, And It Never Was: Olive’s Story

CC image courtesy of Shade Ardent, sagebrushMoon Studios.

HA note: The author’s name has been changed to ensure anonymity. “Olive” is a pseudonym.

I’ve always been autistic.  

Since I was a baby.  Vaccinations didn’t do me in and it wasn’t because my breastfeeding mother or I ate too much milk or gluten.  From the time I was born, I struggled to cope with things like bright lights, loud sounds, and the feeling of having a body.

I learned early that my sensitivities wouldn’t be tolerated, though, and that in order to get by I needed to let people kiss, hug, and touch me even though it often hurt.  Being hungry and tired gave me meltdowns, but my brain couldn’t feel that I was hungry, or tired and so I didn’t know why it was happening or how to stop it and my screaming was often met with threats.

Stop crying or I’ll give you something to cry about.

The threats terrified me, so I taught myself to stop crying and to calm down, which my mother took as proof that I was just being stubborn and strong-willed.  If something were really wrong, then I wouldn’t have been able to stop crying on a whim.

I struggled through elementary, but because my school was small and private (and aggressively evangelical), I stayed with the same 10-15 kids from K-6th grades, so there was stability in that and I always knew I’d have friends at school.  I had trouble relating to other kids and couldn’t easily make friends outside my built-in friend group, but I didn’t have a lot of reason to anyway.  There were plenty of slumber parties and trips to the rollerskating rink as it was.

Then I pretty much failed 6th grade.  It wasn’t out of nowhere.  I had started having issues in fourth grade with the volume of homework, and my mother wasn’t good at offering support, subscribing wholeheartedly to the idea that kids should learn to be responsible by being left fully responsible for as much as possible.  I was blamed for my failures and when my mom took an afternoon off work to come visit my least favorite class with me, it was all over. 

I would be homeschooled, she decided.

Some kids just aren’t cut out for school.

A refrain that would be repeated throughout my junior high and high school years.  It would cripple me.  Completely disempower me.  Because I just wasn’t cut out to deserve the things other kids did, or to be allowed to have peers and friends.

So much happened from 7th grade to 12th, but it feels like a dark hole to me.  It was an ugly time.  When homeschooling didn’t work because I had a single mother and she worked as a nurse for 40 hours a week, she tried to put me in public school in 9th grade.  When that didn’t work, she got me a floppy red set of ACE workbooks and told me that if I wanted to learn, then I would finish them.  When that didn’t work, she got me Saxon math books and started calling what she was doing “unschooling”, which meant that math was the only subject that really mattered anyway, because I could learn all the rest just from being in the world.

When I made friends online to replace the ones I’d lost in school, she took them away too because I called one of them my boyfriend and we weren’t allowed to have romantic relationships until we were 18.

When I couldn’t provide myself with the structure I needed to complete the ACE curriculum, she got me a job babysitting for 8 hours a day.  I bathed, fed, and read to 1, then 2, and eventually 4 little siblings who lived in a small, sticky apartment.

If you aren’t going to complete your school work, then you should at least learn a work ethic.

So, I did.

The anxiety never left.  The social anxiety was worst and I wasn’t able to make friends or even talk openly with people I already knew, but I also had anxiety about my future and how I would survive once I turned 18.  I wasn’t being given anything that my peers were, and it was all my fault because I’d failed so miserably.  There was no school counselor to help me through college applications.  There was no one there to tell my mother that what she was doing was hurting me.  I thought she was only trying to help.

And since there was no one else to blame, I fully blamed myself.

If only I could have kept it together in 6th grade.

If only I could have stayed at public school in 9th grade.

If only I could have finished the ACE curriculum, or the Saxon math.

I am a failure.

I never studied my schoolwork.  It caused too much anxiety.  I never finished the ACE curriculum or the math books.  I snuck back on the computer to my friends, and studied them instead.  They had expansive vocabularies gleaned from philosophy books and collections of novels I’d never heard of because of my conservative upbringing.  They gave me book lists ranging from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance to Ishmael, The Perks of Being a Wallflower to John Grisham novels.  I studied our language, the language of kids online in 1999.  The way we communicated via acronyms and words couched in asterisks.

At 17, I passed the GED with mostly flying colors except for math, which I almost failed but was too afraid to take again.  My mother was calling my “education” unschooling by then.  I wasn’t a neglected child, I was an “autodidact” and this had been my choice.  After all, I could have finished that ACE curriculum like she’d wanted me to.

And I believed her.

Which was the biggest lie homeschooling/unschooling ever told me.

I had no outside influences to tell me anything different.  That I could strive for something greater than an almost-failed GED.  That maybe I could be cut out for school if I had the right support.  That maybe I could have a future.

The only people speaking into my education were my mother and other homeschooling/unschooling family members.  I was young, depressed and broken from years of not having a peer group or any outside support.  Listening to them finally tell me that I was a success felt good, and I clung to it.

No matter that I couldn’t carry on conversations, that I felt awkward and out of place no matter where I went, or that I had no friends in real life.  It didn’t matter that I couldn’t count back change with any accuracy or that I wasn’t ever taught to say no to anyone, resulting in many bad relationships and a traumatizing sexual assault.

If I had taught myself like I was supposed to, I wouldn’t be in this position.

It was like a poison that ate me alive.

I received no explanation of how to choose a college and was simply driven to the local community college one day by my mother and enrolled.  Whether I wanted to go or not was irrelevant.  What I wanted was irrelevant, because my mother wanted me to look like I was succeeding.

Through sheer force of will I was able to keep up and get good grades while working full time and going to school full time.

For one semester.

But after that, everything fell apart again and it was like deja vu.  It cemented for me over and over that what my mother said was true, I just wasn’t cut out for school.

By the time I finally learned that I was autistic, I had given up on school.  I was married, living overseas.  More things made sense, but I still believed that I was broken, unfit for education.  I’ve been a stay-at-home wife for most of our marriage, although I did try school once and had an awful breakdown halfway through the second semester.

My mother seems to view my stay-at-home status as a success though, because women are meant to be at home.

And anyway…

What else would you have had me do with an autistic child who was failing in school?

She demands to know and I feel at a loss.  I don’t know what could have been done in the 90’s for a girl who nobody knew had autism, but I know the answer isn’t: Take them out of school and saddle them with the responsibility of orchestrating their entire education alone.

And I know I wouldn’t do this to any kid I know.  Autistic or not.

Today, I’m still a stay-at-home wife.  We rent a tiny house with a big back yard where I grow tomatoes and strawberries and our dog chases cats and stray chickens.  It took me so long to realize that the lies I’d been told about my education weren’t true, that I’m in my 30’s now and still have no college degree.  In picking apart everything that went wrong, I’ve begun to be estranged from my family.  I gave up my faith, too, and am now an atheist instead of an evangelical Christian.

The transitions have come all at once, like hitting a wall and removing brick after brick just to get to the other side.  I still have meltdowns when I get too hungry, or I’m surprised, or when the weight of all the things feels too much, but I’m learning to be gentler with myself now.  The more bricks I pull away from the wall, the more clearly I can see and it turns out that kindness helps a lot more with supporting my autism than tough love ever did.  I still struggle to make friends and don’t really have any, but hope that as I get healthier through therapy, I may be able to develop more social skills.  And I still don’t know if I’m “cut out” for school, although I hope someday I will be.

I think the one thing I do know now is that autism doesn’t mean I have to hide.  If I am struggling with something, I can ask for help doing that thing.  I don’t need to have the thing taken away from me.  I can get support in being who I am and doing the things I want to do, all at the same time.

And it’s not my fault that I didn’t get the education I deserved. 

It never was.


  • It’s horrendous and totally unfair what happened to you, and you have my deep sympathy. Your mother simply sounds inadequate. Over-stressed, and inadequate. Other mothers could have been helpful, she could not, it’s as simple as that, apart from her also sounding unfairly unsympathetic to you. I hope you can move on from this and be happy and fulfilled!

  • Sounds like you are a survivor. You will reach your own definition of success.

  • For me it was employment. “Obviously” my extremely high verbal intelligence and strong love of order and detail meant that I was destined for high-powered office jobs, so that’s what I was encouraged to strive for, starting as soon as I was old enough to legally get a paycheck. It took me almost 20 years to understand that the glass ceiling I kept hitting was actually inside my brain. I am simply not wired for the squishy human stuff that comes with being in management or even with having co-workers. And my resume reflects that.

    I’m now a mostly-SAHM with a part-time job in which I work alone, to the same pattern every workday, with mostly stereotyped interactions with the people at my work locations (I’m a merchandiser) and a built-in excuse for quickly and politely ending non-stereotyped interactions when I’m getting stressed–after all, we’re all on the clock, me more than most. I am working to the best of my ability. It took me a long time to stop beating up on myself for not magically being able to snap my fingers and not be on the spectrum…but I did get there. Basically I told myself every day, “Look, you did this one thing here well, and that’s good.” And eventually I believed it.

    Hang in there. You have a plan, you’re making progress, and it’s going to keep on getting better–by your definition of better and no one else’s.

  • Olive,
    I was an instructor and teaching assistant at a highly rated state university. The university has an entire department called the Disability Resource Center to assist students with disabilities. Students with learning and other disabilities could receive accommodations such as a longer test time, and note taking assistance. The DRC even had a test taking center where students who needed a distraction free environment could take their exams. Some of my best students were DRC students, and all they needed to excel was a little assistance.

    I am very sorry that you are a victim of educational neglect. To hand a high school student, even a neurotypical teenager, a set of books and telling her to finish without any assistance is to set her up for failure. Most high school students need assistance finishing their education. The fact that you made good grades for a semester while working full time demonstrates that you have the ability to succeed in college. When you are ready to attend college, be sure to visit the disability resource center of your school. With a few accommodations, you will be able to succeed.

  • Your mother sounds like toxic person, who possibly didn’t want children, when you were born. It was not you-she just hated her life. It’s great that in spite of everything, you DID find allies and you married and you have your own “real life” now. Not surprising that you grew estranged from your relatives and dislike Christianity. I personally have no use for the organized version(church) and don’t bother to attend one. If your mother is STILL toxic, I hope that you will allow yourself to avoid her and not let her wreck your life, as she did in your youth !

  • No, it was not your fault.
    I bet that part of the reason that you did badly at school was because your mom forced you to use up tremendous amounts of energy holding your emotions in. Doing that might have meant that you had no energy left for doing schoolwork, and your mom blamed you when really it was her unrealistic demands. Meltdowns are incredibly hard to suppress, and it makes sense that the effort to do so would make it impossible to do schoolwork because schoolwork requires a lot of focus as well.

  • I hope that you get better and find friends, online or in real life, who are loving and supportive of you. I hope you will be okay with yourself, no matter what that okay is. My family was similarly horrible, and more physically violent when my response to their threats was always to increase my volume. I hope that you can recover from what was done to you and that the people responsible receive all that they deserve for their cruelty.

  • aDorkablyDelish

    Aside from the home schooling (or unschooling), this could be my own story. I’m in my mid-forties, so Autism wasn’t even considered when I was a child. My parents did not know what to do with me, and I grew up with beatings and punishments and verbal abuse. To this day, they don’t consider their behavior abusive. My entire life I have felt like a loser because I can’t function the way I’m “supposed” to. I spent a lot of time abusing alcohol and letting men abuse me. I neer understood why, outside of what I had been taught: I was a liar and a slut and a drunk and I would never live up to my potential. I didn’t even know what that meant! How can you tell a kid to do something or act a certain way, and not give them any guidance? How can a parent use the same abusive tactics over and over again, and not see that it’s making the situation worse? 40 some-odd years, I felt like a complete waste of life.

    I only discovered I was on the Spectrum when I had my son evaluated, like a lot of parents, I think. Although this did a world of good for helping me understand myself and my son, I still struggle with other people believing me. They think I’m faking, or I’m blaming myself for my son’s “affliction”. It really sucks, and makes me want to live in a shack in the woods and not interact with anyone aside from my son.

    I’m so sorry this happened to you, Olive. Know you’re not alone.

  • It was definitely not your fault, and I’m sorry you were neglected so badly by your mother, your state’s homeschooling oversight, and your other family members.

    I am also autistic and was homeschooled and expected to teach myself after a certain point. My situation was not as bad as yours, but it had negative effects that have still not gone completely away, even now that I’m in my mid-thirties.

    Public schools can be damaging for autistic kids, but the kind of homeschooling that removes kids from all outside influences and requires them to teach themselves isn’t a solution. It’s an alternate form of neglect and abuse. And it’s harder to speak up about because the reaction can be so dismissive.

    You are brave for speaking out—not just for speaking out for something that other people sometimes respond badly to, but for writing about things that are difficult and painful to think about. I tried to write an entry for this event and couldn’t manage to get through all the emotions. Maybe someday.

  • > my school was small and private (and aggressively evangelical)

    I think this is the most ironic thing I’ve ever read.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s