The Power of False History: Nicholas’ Story
CC image courtesy of Flickr, Ryan Hyde.
HA Note: This is a preview of our upcoming Lightbulb Moments series. We would love for you to contribute your story as well.
By Nicholas Ducote, HA Community Coordinator
My “lightbulb” moment in my youth, which convinced me of the lies that my upbringing was filled with, centered around the study of history. I was interested in history from a very young age, and my parents made sure to purchase fundamentalist American history for me to study. The Light and the Glory and From Sea to Shining Sea by Peter Manual and David Marshall, alongside Foxes Book of Martyrs, David Barton and Little Bear Wheeler’s histories, made up most of my historical and political education. But the history written by these men are filled with fallacies, false history, cherry-picked examples, and gross misinterpretation of historical events.
The main thesis of all these histories was that the Christian God was responsible for the prosperity experienced by the United States. From Christopher Columbus, to the Conquistadors, Plymouth Rock, and the American Revolution, the European conquest of the Americas was portrayed as Christians harvesting souls for the Lord and the Lord blessing them. Columbus was a pious missionary – no mention of him riding on the backs of natives for sport and exacting untold violence on innocents. The genocide against native tribes was “mission work” and “fixing them.”
Constructing this false history was vital to mobilizing Evangelicals and fundamentalists into contemporary political action.
The most important goal was to influence American politics “back to Jesus/Christianity.” The establishment of theocratic laws depends on convincing people that the US Constitution means whatever the Founding Fathers, in their eminent foresight and wisdom, meant it to mean. Supreme Court be damned.
My parents pushed me into the Christian homeschool debate league (NCFCA) at 15, and I began developing critical thinking skills. I remember my first big political debate with my dad (where I believed differently) was over whether we should drill for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge – it was a topic during energy policy year. By the time I was 18, I began to read scholars and historians that disagreed about the foundation of the United States.
I originally intended to only educate myself about the enemy so I could better defeat those damn socialists in an argument, but my research demonstrated that so many “experts” in the homeschooling world were frauds.
They cherry-picked facts and characters, while ignoring all nuance and complexity for their over-simplified, overly-political narratives. It took me four years in a political science bachelors and another 18 months in a graduate program for history to feel like I finally had a firm, realistic grasp of American and world history.
In my final graduate term, I studied Islamic nationalism in communist Eastern Europe and central Asia. Just like the Christian fundamentalists, the militant religious-nationalist factions (Orthodox Serbs, Muslim Kosovars, Bulgarians, and Bosnians, and Catholic Croats), invented history and conflict to motivate their constituents to fight with each other. Everything became clear. People who wanted power created a false history to rally homeschooling parents to a fight what really didn’t exist. Our government has always striven to be secular, and just because a few Founders were Christians doesn’t mean they wanted the United States to be a Theocracy.
The Christian homeschooling movement encourages an intrinsic cognitive dissonance about history.
They praise and almost worship the American Revolution, individualism, liberty and freedom, but then turn around and wish for more theocratic laws that favor their flavor of religion. Fundamentalism of all religions is typically anti-democratic.
The best example of this would be the patriarchal ideas found in the Homeschooling Movement. The spectrum of religiously-motivated sexism, from Complementarianism to outright-Patriarchy, is founded in anti-democratic ideals that women should not have the same civil rights as men. My mom actually believes that the United States started going astray when women were given the right to vote.
By consigning women to the domestic sphere, fundamentalists want to restrict or completely deny women access to the public sphere and civil engagement.
I could not reconcile the sexist, Patriarchal ideas with the stark liberalism of the Founders. I decided that to advocate for laws based on my views of religion would be no better than implementing Shari’a law. I became an outspoken liberal feminist in college, but not because I was “brainwashed,” as my parents would have my family believe. But, for the first time in my life, I had access to an array of scholars, knowledge, and philosophies.
No one brainwashes me, I make up my own damn mind.
Well said Nicholas, well said. This is very similar to my own story. We make up our own mind.
“My mom actually believes that the United States started going astray when women were given the right to vote.”
YES YES YES.
Mr. McBride, one of the A Beka video teachers for history, actually told us that he believed women shouldn’t vote because women make decisions based on emotion and men were logical.
He said women should be submissive and vote exactly as their husbands did, to defy our evil feminist government.
But now? I vote for my own self. ❤
Converse: And we better stay on God’s Good Side (AKA NO POUFTAS!) or God will start to PUNISH America instead.
“God’s Judgment for America’s Sins Sits Ready And Waiting in The Nuclear Missile Silos Of The Soviet Union!!!!!”
— Radio preacher of the late Cold War
You know what this “false history” really is?
IT’S THE MYTHOLOGY OF A “GRIEVANCE CULTURE”, i.e. a Culture whose only reason for existence is Revenge Upon the Other.
A Grievance Culture is built around three axioms:
1) “Once WE were Lords of All Creation, and Everything Was PERFECT.”
2) “Then THEY came and took it all away from us.”
3) “IT’S PAYBACK TIME! WITH INTEREST!”
The best-known example of an Extreme Grievance Culture is Nazi Germany, with the current outbreaks of Extreme Islam a la ISIS and the Taliban a fast-closing second. Other examples are the original Ku Klux Klan after the American Civil War and some of the Afrocentric “Black Messiah” cults.
What fascinates me is just how powerful these triumphalists narratives can be. You can show them wrong time and again, but the faithful will not be shaken. It’s a damned shame.