You Can Probably Guess What the Founder of “Biblical Counseling” Said About Domestic Violence
By R.L. Stollar, HA Community Coordinator
Jay E. Adams is the founder of the “nouthetic counseling” movement, or what has become known as “biblical counseling” (though it is unworthy of being called either “biblical” or “counseling” in my opinion). Popularized by Adams’ seminal book Competent to Counsel, nouthetic counseling is based on the assumption that counseling should be based solely upon the Bible. This movement rejects mainstream psychology and therapeutic methods as secular and atheistic and thus ungodly.
The movement also assumes that pastors and other spiritual leaders — untrained in the actual practice and science of mental health — can adequately address mental illness because mental illness in this perspective is basically another word for sin. Adams’ method is currently championed by eminent evangelical Christians such as John MacArthur, who claims “behavioral sciences…are not scientific,” psychology is an “occult religion,” and Jesus and the Bible should be “the church’s only solution” to mental illness. This is the same method and mentality that respected (and formerly respected) leaders in the Christian Homeschool Movement — most notably Voddie Baucham, Reb Bradley, Doug Phillips, and Bill Gothard — have promoted for years. They have taught thousands of families at homeschool and other religious conventions around the country — and through their books and other educational materials — that mental “illness” is fake. It’s all just “sin” and “rebellion” and can be resolved through a “right” relationship with God.
An example of Adams chalking up mental illness to sin comes from his book Helps for Counselors: A Mini-Manual for Christian Counseling, published by Baker Book House in 1980. On page 29, under his section explaining how a counselor should deal with a client’s depression, Adams says, “The counsel must recognize his responsibility for depression” (emphasis added). A client has spiritual guilt for his or her own depression because, in Adams’ worldview, “Depression results from handling a down period sinfully.” Thus “counselees may spiral up out of depression by asking God’s forgiveness” and “can stay out depression by following God’s commands” and “repenting of any sin immediately.”
If you think Adams handles depression poorly, just wait until you see how he handles domestic violence.
The following passage is also from Adams’ Helps for Counselors, pages 19-20. In these pages Adams is addressing the importance of “Listening.” He writes,
III. Listen for all of the facts (Prov. 18:17).
A. There are two or more sides to many issues:
1. This implies that all parties should be present if possible,
2. That each should hear what the other says in order to explain, modify, amplify, etc. (note “examine”),
3. And it is clear that one must not be allowed to speak negatively about another behind his back (see also James 4:11).
B. The first to speak can sound quite convincing if heard alone,
1. But the additional information that the other provides can turn the conclusion about face.
2. As, for instance, when one counselee said,
“He hit me! He slapped me in the face!”
And her husband replied:
“Sure, to bring her to her senses.”
“To bring her to her senses.” Apparently that makes it okay!
Other posts on HA about domestic violence:
- How Christian Homeschool Leaders Have Addressed Domestic Violence Isn’t OK
- James Dobson on Domestic Violence: Women “Deliberately Bait” Their Husbands
- Mary Pride: Don’t Divorce Your Drunk, Raging Husband
- How Not to Address Marriage or Child Abuse
- Michael Farris on Domestic Abuse: “Far Cry From the ‘Battered-Woman Syndrome'”
Note: if you are a victim of domestic violence or know someone who is, please call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 (SAFE) or visit their website here. There is help available and you are worth it.
These people can help the cause of Christ and the Church much better by just keeping their ‘knowledgeable’ senseless mouths SHUT. And that’s not the first time I’ve thought to say that about their teachings.
Scientology says the exact same thing.
Just substitute “Dianetic Auditing and Elron’s Tech” for “Jesus and the Bible”.
This is just sickening. How barbaric.
It’s my observation that the more frightened people are of something (or lots of things), the more likely they are to watch black/white answers to complex questions and problems overall. To latch onto what this person has to say and truly believe it, they must be terrified of their own shadows.
Pingback: Five Things Homeschool Moms Should Know About Abusive Marriages « HARO
I had a friend who was unfortunate enough to become a victim of nouthetic counseling. She was bi-polar with a history of suicide attempts. Her nouthetic counselor told her that taking her medicine for her bipolar disorder was sin because she was not trusting God. At his counsel, she stopped taking her pills cold turkey and then committed suicide within days.
The author of this article baited you with a story about domestic violence and how Jay Adams supposedly deals with it in Nouthetic Counseling. An excerpt from one of Jay’s books was given which began… III. Listen for all the facts (Proverbs 18:17). Then it gives a perfect example of what Jay says not to do. It only gives you the part (a quote) the author of the article wants you to see. Then Stellar, instead of finishing the quote, paraphrases it to try to emphasize his point.
I just pulled Jay Adam’s book off my shelf to see the context of the quote Stellar used from it in the article which is as follows.
“‘Sure I slapped her,’ Phillip replied, ‘but only to stop her from beating herself with her fists in a hysterical rage’.”
Shame on you Mr. Stellar. How can you quote a man using his own words about the importance of listening to both sides of the story and the try to slander him by trying to hide part of his side?
That is exactly the point of Proverbs 18:17 and the point that Adams was making. Listen for all the facts. One side often sounds right until you hear the other side.
I was pursuing a degree in psychology and received a BS in organizational behavior. I also received training in Nouthetic Counseling. This article grossly misrepresents the later.